Arne's Rotten Apples for the Teachers

Three times this week, I was asked by colleagues for advice on some of their 'trickier' students. Gladly, I helped. I feel honored when one of my oh-so-very amazing colleagues asks me for an idea. We all know who to go to in our building for the best Science ideas, Art integrated centers; we know who always finds the best poems or songs that help teach concepts or content. Each and every teacher in our building brings unique strengths to our school, making us all better teachers.

In a competitive atmosphere, I'm not sure this sharing attitude will continue into the next generation of teachers. Why would anyone want to help someone else get better if it could possibly mean helping another teacher get a 'higher batting average'? That could put your own job at stake. I love teaching, but I hope I'm not around if and/or when schools and teachers become that way for their own survival.


Below is one of the best letters to Arne Duncan I've seen yet.  

Mr. Duncan, you are a shining example

• Add a comment

David Reber

, Topeka K-12 Examiner

May 21, 2011 - Like this? Subscribe to get instant updates.

• 215
• 21
• 
  
• 0
• 0

  Submit
• 0

  reddit
• Print
• Email

Mr. Duncan,

I read your Teacher Appreciation Week letter to teachers, and had at first decided not to respond. Upon further thought, I realized I do have a few things to say.

I’ll begin with a small sample of relevant adjectives just to get them out of the way: condescending, arrogant, insulting,

misleading, patronizing, egotistic, supercilious, haughty, insolent, peremptory, cavalier, imperious, conceited,

contemptuous, pompous, audacious, brazen, insincere, superficial, contrived, garish, hollow, pedantic, shallow,

swindling, boorish, predictable, duplicitous, pitchy, obtuse, banal, scheming, hackneyed, and quotidian. Again,

it’s just a small sample; but since your attention to teacher input is minimal, I wanted to put a lot into the first

Advertisement

paragraph.

Your lead sentence, “I have worked in education for much of my life”, immediately establishes your tone of

condescension; for your 20-year “education” career lacks even one day as a classroom teacher. You, Mr.

Duncan, are the poster-child for the prevailing attitude in corporate-style education reform: that the number one

prerequisite for educational expertise is never having been a teacher.

Your stated goal is that teachers be “…treated with the dignity we award to other professionals in society.”

Really?

How many other professionals are the last ones consulted about their own profession; and are then summarily

ignored when policy decisions are made? How many other professionals are so distrusted that sweeping federal

legislation is passed to “force” them to do their jobs? And what dignities did you award teachers when you

publicly praised the mass firing of teachers in Rhode Island?

You acknowledge teacher’s concerns about No Child Left Behind, yet you continue touting the same old

rhetoric: “In today’s economy, there is no acceptable dropout rate, and we rightly expect all children – English-

language learners, students with disabilities, and children of poverty - to learn and succeed.”

What other professions are held to impossible standards of perfection? Do we demand that police officers

eliminate all crime, or that doctors cure all patients? Of course we don’t.

There are no parallel claims of “in today’s society, there is no acceptable crime rate”, or “we rightly expect all

patients – those with end-stage cancers, heart failure, and multiple gunshot wounds – to thrive into old age.”

When it comes to other professions, respect and common sense prevail.

Your condescension continues with “developing better assessments so [teachers] will have useful information

to guide instruction…” Excuse me, but I am a skilled, experienced, and licensed professional. I don’t need

an outsourced standardized test – marketed by people who haven’t set foot in my school – to tell me how my

students are doing.

I know how my students are doing because I work directly with them. I learn their strengths and weaknesses

through first-hand experience, and I know how to tailor instruction to meet each student’s needs. To suggest

otherwise insults both me and my profession.

You want to “…restore the status of the teaching profession...” Mr. Duncan, you built your career defiling the

teaching profession. Your signature effort, Race to the Top, is the largest de-professionalizing, demoralizing,

sweeter-carrot-and-sharper-stick public education policy in U.S. history.  You literally bribed cash-starved

states to enshrine in statute the very reforms teachers have spoken against.

You imply that teachers are the bottom-feeders among academics. You want more of “America’s top

college students” to enter the profession. If by “top college students” you mean those with high GPA’s from

prestigious, pricey schools then the answer is simple: a five-fold increase in teaching salaries.

You see, Mr. Duncan, those “top” college students come largely from our nation’s wealthiest families. They

simply will not spend a fortune on an elite college education to pursue a 500% drop in socioeconomic status

relative to their parents.

You assume that “top” college students automatically make better teachers. How, exactly, will a 21-year-old,

silver-spoon-fed ivy-league graduate establish rapport with inner-city kids? You think they’d be better at

it than an experienced teacher from a working-class family, with their own rough edges or checkered past, who

can actually relate to those kids? Your ignorance of human nature is astounding.

As to your concluding sentence, “I hear you, I value you, and I respect you”; no, you don’t, and you don’t, and

you don’t. In fact, I don’t believe you even wrote this letter for teachers.

I think you sense a shift in public opinion. Parents are starting to see through the façade; and recognize the

privatization and for-profit education reform movement for what it is. And they’ve begun to organize – Parents

Across America, is one example.

To save yourself, you need to reinforce the illusion that you’re doing what’s best for public education. So you

play nice with teachers for one day - not for the teachers but for your public audience.

You also need to reassure those who leverage their wealth – and have clearly bought your loyalties – that you’re

still on their side. Your letter is riddled with all the right buzzwords and catch phrases to do just that:

“…to change and improve federal law to invest in teachers” sounds like a wink-nod to TFA that federal dollars

are headed their way.

“…sophisticated assessment that measures individual student growth” can be nothing other than value-added

standardized testing; a mill-stone for teachers but a boon to the for-profit testing industry.

“…transform teaching from the factory model…to one built for the information age” alludes to systemic

replacement of living teachers with virtual ones – bolstering the near monopoly of one software giant who

believes the “babysitting” function of public schools is the only reason not to go 100% virtual.

“…recognize and reward great teaching” is stale code for “merit pay”; which is stale code for “bribe for test

scores”; which comes down to “justification to pay most teachers less.” Lower teacher salaries, in turn, will

free up money for standardized tests, new computer software, and other profitable pursuits.

No doubt some will dismiss what I’ve said as paranoid delusion. What they call paranoia I call paying

attention. Mr. Duncan, teachers hear what you say. We also watch what you do, and we are paying attention.

Working with kids every day, our baloney-detectors are in fine form. We’ve heard the double-speak before;

and we don’t believe the dog ate your homework. Coming from children, double-speak is expected and it

provides important teachable moments. Coming from adults, it’s just sad.

Despite our best efforts, some folks never outgrow their disingenuous, manipulative, self-serving approach to

life. Of that, Mr. Duncan, you are a shining example

Continue reading on Examiner.com Mr. Duncan, you are a shining example - Topeka K-12 | Examiner.com http://www.examiner.com/k-12-in-topeka/mr-duncan-you-are-a-shining-example#ixzz1k6g21KPO